find Howard on...
The Howard League
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • History
  • Around Aotearoa
    • Around Aotearoa
    • Wellington Branch
    • Canterbury Branch
    • Otago Branch
  • Research
    • Latest Work
    • Fact Sheets
    • Reports
    • Press Releases
  • Contribute
    • Join/Donate
    • Volunteer
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • General
    • Media

Child sex offender registries - do they work?

8/20/2015

4 Comments

 
PictureAlthough New Zealand's registry will be accessible only by government agencies, registration laws overseas can include mandatory public notification, and prevent access to some areas such as those near schools.
It looks as though New Zealand will soon be instituting a mandatory registration system for child sex offenders. There is perhaps a no more heinous crime than child sex offending and paedophilia, so the suggestion of keeping tabs on convicted child sex offenders upon their release from prison can seem like something to celebrate.  However, before the government gets their cheque book out and throws down the cash to get the register running, let’s look at the facts.

 The purpose of the child sex offender registry is to identify, monitor and manage the risk posed by convicted child sex offenders who have come to the end of their sentence.  The goal is to be able to stop the sex offenders in their tracks if they act suspiciously or as a threat to public safety.  The offenders will be monitored for periods of time ranging from 8 years to a lifetime, dependent on the scale of their offending.
 
It seems like a suitable political response to quell public fears of sex offenders running rampant on the streets.  Not a hard idea for politicians to sell to the public.  What comes with this is a greater perceived sense of security.  People can sleep easy knowing that child sex offenders are accounted for.  But does it work?

Reports on the effectiveness of similar oversees models hardly act as compelling reading in favour of the register.  Studies from the United States have indicated that sex offender registers have little to no impact on reoffending rates. A recent Australian study has found that on balance, the evidence available does not support the idea that sex offender registries are an effective means of reducing recidivism.  Bang for the taxpayer’s buck? Apparently not.

We cannot ignore the fact that 65% of perpetrators committing a sexual act against children in New Zealand have a family relationship with the child victim.  What is the value of accounting for child sex offenders for up to a lifetime when we already know where a large proportion of them are? They are in our homes. 

A 2011 Department of Corrections study has shown that 30% of child sex offenders were convicted of a new offence within 5 years of being released from prison.  This is well below the 52% average re-imprisonment rate for all released prisoners within 5 years.  This is even lower than that of the reconviction rate of sexual offences against adults which sits at 35%. So we do have to ask, why is the registry initiative only extending to sexual offences against children?

So why sex offenders?  We would all agree that child sex offending is the worst of the worst, but if we are looking to increase public safety, why not have a register for recidivist armed burglars? Or a register for convicted murders? Where do we draw the line?  Should we have all convicted criminals on a register?

Alternatively, we have options such as redirecting funding to programs that actually reduce reoffending. One such programme with known benefits is the Kia Marama treatment programme for child sex offenders.  An evaluation has found an 8% recidivism rate for child sex offenders who successfully completed the programme. That’s an incredible result for any rehabilitation programme. In-prison programmes like this have yielded very real, meaningful results and are less invasive than a child sex offender registry. In this case we may be better served investing in services that have proven track records of success. 

This project will carry a price in the millions of dollars, but there is no international evidence that it will reduce offending at all. Instead simply plays upon hysteria without creating any less victims. The implementation of a registry may be an easy sell with politicians and the general public, but not so much with the evidence. 

4 Comments
comprar viagra link
2/19/2018 08:17:34 am

Generic Viagra 100mg, an impotence remedy for impotent men, contains sildenafil citrate. Low price offered, Buy Generic Viagra online at discount price. Check prices, availability.

Reply
porn videos link
3/11/2018 09:18:17 am

Block porn. A simple statement that gets overlooked by many parents. That is until they happen to look on their teens computer and find all kind of pornography!

Reply
indian cams link
3/16/2018 09:20:50 am

Love and sex: Across different cultures, issues related to sex and love are handled differently. Whether the settings are in a rural form or a cosmopolitan area, there is always tension among many communities' sexual habits and customs on what they believe to be the proper context of love. Across different cultures even in the western world, many people prefer sexual passion to romance and companionship and there is no culture which is known to regard both passion and affection equally.

Reply
milf cam chat link
3/16/2018 09:35:38 am

Sex is an all important issue that is treated like the silent elephant in the room. In other countries outside of The good ole U.S. of A. they have a more relaxed and mature approach to sex. This perspective results in less problems surrounding our elephant in question.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Word from the League

    We hope to keep you up to date with relevant issue is the areas of crime and justice in New Zealand. And this is where it will happen. We hope you find this page useful and informative.

    Archives

    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014

    Categories

    All
    Misc

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
✕